Skip to main content

COP31: The COP of implementation becomes the COP of shame

Photos from the COP31 Shame Action by CSOs and allies.

The EU and other developed countries bear primary responsibility for a shameful failure to deliver. The EU’s rejection of the proposed cover decision does not erase its contribution to that compromise, while the Turkish and Australian presidencies failed to secure an outcome that meets the urgency of the crisis.

COP31 has failed to deliver the ambition, finance and cooperation needed to turn climate commitments into action. The EU and other developed countries hiding behind it bear primary responsibility for leaving developing countries without credible assurances of support, while the Turkish and Australian presidencies failed to bridge divisions and secure meaningful progress. The proposed cover decision is shamefully weak. But the EU’s rejection of it does not erase the role its own positions played in producing it. Across fossil fuels, adaptation finance and just transition, the promise of implementation has given way to further delay.

“The COP of implementation has become the COP of shame. As the world heats up and climate impacts are felt everywhere, the EU’s weakened ambition and slow delivery have helped turn COP31 into a collective failure. The EU cannot contribute to a shameful compromise, then claim the climate high ground for rejecting it.”

Climate finance: promises without a credible delivery plan

The finance provisions remain overwhelmingly procedural. The EU resisted the central political question: how will it deliver its own commitments to support developing countries to cut emissions, adapt and respond to loss and damage? Further reports, discussions and a roadmap do not provide the predictable support vulnerable countries need. Even the baseline and delivery pathway for tripling adaptation finance are left for further work in the proposed cover text, despite the growing needs it acknowledges. The EU’s failure to clarify its own delivery helped leave this central issue unresolved.

“Lack of finance has already weakened climate ambition. Now it is preventing even those weakened commitments from being delivered. The EU cannot demand that developing countries transform their economies while refusing to clarify how it will honor its own obligations and commitments. By choosing ambiguity over accountability, it undermines the Global South’s ability to act, as well as its own ambitions to green the world’s financial flows.”

Fossil fuels: no clear direction out of fossil fuel dependence

The proposed cover text fails to explicitly commit to transitioning away from fossil fuels. Its target for electricity to reach 35% of final energy consumption by 2035 neither requires that electricity to be clean nor explicitly links electrification to transitioning away from fossil fuels. Historical polluters escape a clear demand to lead the transition. Yet the EU’s weakened ambition and slow delivery undermined its own credibility, and it failed to stand firm on clean electrification. Rejecting the text over fossil fuels, without delivering its own credible phase-out plan, does not erase its contribution to the conditions that produced this failure.

Just transition: practical support deferred again

The failure to secure a dedicated, inclusive body to put the just transition mechanism into operation leaves a central promise to workers and communities unfulfilled. More discussions cannot substitute for arrangements that coordinate practical support, expertise and access to resources. A transition cannot be just if countries are expected to deliver economic transformation while the means to support people through it remain unresolved. By treating that support as negotiable, the EU undermined the trust and cooperation needed to secure a stronger agreement.

“By treating a just transition, climate justice and support for vulnerable countries as negotiable, then claiming moral credit for rejecting the outcome, the EU has further isolated itself from the Global South partners it needed to bring with it. This is not just a failure of solidarity. It is a foreign-policy failure. The EU cannot defend multilateralism while hollowing out the principles and commitments that make it work. COP31 promised ‘dialogue, consensus, action’. The Turkish and Australian presidencies delivered ‘dialogue, deadlock, delay’.”